Saturday 9 May 2015

When democracy gives way to shamocracy

The dust is settling on Thursday's elections and it's becoming increasingly obvious that the first past the post system has got to change.

It is absolutely indefensible that 1 in 8 votes went to UKIP yet there will only be one UKIP MP taking the oath of allegiance next week when the SDLP will have three MPs after securing just 2.57% of the number of votes UKIP did and the SNP will have 56 MPs from two and a half times fewer votes.

PartyVotes%MPsVotes per MP
Conservative11,334,92036.9%33134,244
Labour9,344,32830.4%23240,277
UKIP3,881,12912.6%13,881,129
Lib Dem2,415,8887.9%8301,986
SNP1,454,4364.7%5625,972
Green1,181,6943.7%11,181,694
DUP184,2600.6%823,033
Plaid181,6940.6%360,566
UUP114,9350.4%257,468
SDLP99,8090.3%333,270

If the other parties had to secure as many votes per MP as UKIP did they would still be counting the 2.5bn votes for the foreseeable future but the House of Commons would be pretty empty if their MPs cost the same number of votes as UKIP's did with just 7 MPs sitting on the famous green benches.

PartyUKIP votes needed for MPsMPs by UKIP votes
Conservative1,284,653,699.003
Labour900,421,928.002
UKIP3,881,129.001
Lib Dem31,049,032.001
SNP217,343,224.000
Green3,881,129.000
DUP31,049,032.000
Plaid11,643,387.000
UUP7,762,258.000
SDLP11,643,387.000

First past the post just isn't working, it is disenfranchising millions of voters. It's hard to calculate how many MPs each of the parties would have got under a system of proportional representation but as a rough guide by allocating MPs by vote share things would have been a little more balanced.

PartyMPs under PR
Conservative242
Labour200
UKIP83
Lib Dem52
SNP31
Green25
DUP4
Plaid4
UUP2
SDLP2

UKIP should join the Electoral Reform Society's campaign for electoral reform not out of self-interest but the national interest. The electoral system we have now is a sham. It's not democracy, it's a shamocracy. If we are to have a government that represents everybody and not the biggest minority then we need some form of proportional representation.