Sunday, 26 February 2017

Lib Dem candidate tells Shneur Odze being an Orthodox Jew makes him unsuitable to be Manchester Mayor

UKIP's candidate for Manchester's metro-mayor, Shneur Odze, has been told by Lib Dem candidate Cllr Jane Brophy that he shouldn't be allowed to be a candidate because he's an Orthodox Jew.



Cllr Brophy took issue with the fact that Odze is unable to shake the hand of a woman due to his observation of Orthodox Judaism. She told a hustings that he was unsuitable for the mayoralty because of his religion.

It is an unusual religious observance in this country but it is a religious observance nonetheless. If Cllr Brophy was invited to the local mosque would she refuse to cover herself up? If she was invited to a gurdwara would she sit on the men's side of the Diwan Hall? Of course she wouldn't. So what is it that makes those religious requirements something she can tolerate but not Shneur Odze's?

If politicians are going to allow someone's religion to influence their morals then they need to be consistent. You either respect all religious intolerances or none of them.

Comments (3)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
william grist's avatar

william grist · 419 weeks ago

to say I am shocked would be an understatement, but more shocking still was the applause for this lib dem woman
Martin Wright's avatar

Martin Wright · 419 weeks ago

If a person can be rejected as a candidate for being Jewish, how can Sadiq Khan be allowed to be mayor of London? For that matter, how can any Muslim be allowed to be mayor anywhere in Britain? Libdem double standards, again! Not that her views are relevant, her party is irrelevant.
alan ackbar's avatar

alan ackbar · 419 weeks ago

The Liberal Democrats allies are a party called Fianna Fail the founder of which signed the book of condolence when Hitler shot himself and who persecuted and imprisoned Irish men who fought against fascism and gave sanctuary to war criminals.

Post a new comment

Comments by