Saturday, 28 December 2013

It's going to be 2014 and we still have FPTP


In 2013 we have witnessed spectacular technological breakthroughs as a planet, with artificial intelligence with greater intelligence, smart watches, the XBox One, and the Japanese have even  managed to teleport a particle from point A to point B; but back at home manage to cling onto exceeding ancient realms. One of those is the voting system for general elections - the First Past The Post.

Frankly, how can anyone wake up in the morning with such a disastrously unrepresentative voting system? It's a serious issue that has to be dealt with, especially in a epoch when Britain is entering a crampy interval of five party politics, including Ukip and the LibLabConSNP - which will soon be four with the bump off of the Liberal Democrats. And ultimately we are in very colourful interval in British politics with LabCon only achieving 67% of the vote in 2010, the SNP has an overall majority in Scotland, Ukip's successes in various European and local elections and the different range of political parties dominating Northern Ireland.

I've never found sense in pointing out the flaws of FPTP to MPs because, simply, they know the flaws only too well. You want a scandal? There's a massive one right under our noses crippling any opposition to the two main parties, establishing 'safe seats' where party bosses can cherry pick their whipped candidates and the apparent victories of candidates with an, often extreme, minority of their constituents' vote - 66.6% to be precise. 

The AV referendum was a very cunning distraction to an exceedingly serious debate but few are ever going to be at peace until we have a proportional system that has MPs representing constituents. A lead campaign tactic seemed to be the fortunes of extremist parties under reform. It was not understood that in the eyes of democracy there is no such thing as a political party which must be excluded from the political process; and besides, it was unlikely to see any extremes under AV. 

FPTP's golden monkey has always been that it continually assembles strong, stable government, however that has no longer been the case  and that case seems more and more inane as both failed old parties lose voters to others, particularly Ukip. There is the Single Transferable Vote which is relatively proportional AND provides strong, stable government, like is seen in Northern Ireland and New Zealand. All that will solve this democratic deficit is a grassroots movement thoughout the country, because this set of MPs have absolutely nothing to offer which would make real change.

Let's enter 2014 with our eyes open.

Comments (3)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
The problem with PR is that it leads to coalitions that are party cosy-ups and MP's represent party not people. Rather like what we have now. I can well imagine the Lib Dems using PR to remain permanently in government, just like the Free Democrats used to be in West Germany.
Do you really want the Lib Dems permanently in government and thus fireproof to the voters? Do you want a permanent coalition of pro-EU parties, with UKIP shut out unless it gets over 50% of the vote? That is what will happen under PR.

AV is much better; FPTP even will work for UKIP if UKIP gets over 37% of the total vote in a four party system. The challenge for UKIP is to reach that tipping point. Then the fun starts.
A good article with some valid points made.
Given the current political situation the Liberals may cease to exist as an effective party in 2015 and it will be a 2 way fight between the Conservatives and Labour, unless UKIP steps into the vacuum. However given the current system hundreds of thousands of our supporters will not be represented in parliament due to the current system.
1 reply · active 585 weeks ago
Its not the fault of FTPT or ''the system.'

With FPTP it pays to concentrate your vote, as Caroline Lucas and George Galloway have done, as the Alliance Party did in East Belfast and Plaid Cymru has been doing in Caernavon and in Meirrionydd since the 1970's. It is a trick that even the Lib Dems, who have previously railed against FPTP are learning, as FPTP is now starting to help them keep their seats as their vote falls.

UKIP can't get a majority under PR without >50^ of the vote. With FPTP it needs only 37% on an even spread vote. On a concentrated vote it could win with 29% of the vote in a four party system.

Post a new comment

Comments by